Comprehensive research on leafroll virus in South African vineyards is at an advanced stage and should shed light on various significant aspects of this widespread disease. However, the exact extent of this disease will remain a mystery.
This has emerged from interviews with various role players in the relevant industry organisations with a view to determining the progress made with research and measures to combat the disease, following reports in the international media two years ago, suggesting that up to half the country's vineyards were infested.
In September 2001 a Winetech press statement said that measures were being considerably improved and a sound foundation which should dramatically decrease the incidence and spread of leafroll in the next five years was being laid.
It now appears that good progress with research and a combined strategy to curb the disease has been made over a wide front, but nobody is able (or willing?) to give statistics on the incidence of the disease. Not even an educated estimate could be solicited.
The approach appears to be that measuring the total incidence of leafroll does not serve much of a purpose and that all efforts should be concentrated on ensuring that newly established vineyards are clean and kept clean. Also that it is just about impossible to measure the extent for various practical reasons e g that a white grape vineyard does not necessarily show the symptoms, unlike a red grape vineyard.
According to Dr Johan Burger of the University of Stellenbosch, who heads the reorganised virus programme - in collaboration with Winetech - an important study is well under way and preliminary results will be published before the end of 2003. This is on the incidence and spread of leafroll disease in mother blocks and will, however, not show the bigger picture.
"It would be dangerous to claim that the incidence and spread of leafroll have diminished," explains Dr Burger. "It's simply unrealistic to expect this to have happened in two years. Keep in mind that once a vineyard is infected, it stays infected until it's replaced and that it will always serve as a potential virus source for secondary spread."
Dr Burger, however, concludes that "most producers are very serious about using only virus-free plant material and are implementing some of the prescribed 'management' measures. We are confident that this trend will ensure medium term benefits for the industry.
"Our short-term strategy is to 'manage' the current situation. A number of research projects aim to yield practical measures to prevent the planting of infected material, to prevent secondary spread in vineyards, to control natural vectors of the viruses and give guidelines on how to 'handle' infected grapes. Popular publications (leaflets) on leafroll disease and on the monitoring and control of the mealy bug vector have been distributed and are still available from ARC-Infruitec/Nietvoorbij."
WineLand asked Dr Burger to respond to the fact that the foreign press reports were slated as negative and exaggerated, if - even today - there are no reliable statistics available to show the contrary.
"As far as I know, a number of local producers were interviewed and these people gave their personal opinions about virus incidence and spread. None of these comments were based on any scientific study," says Dr Burger.
Although some experts say that the virus has no detrimental effect whatsoever on the consumer - saying that top wines of international quality have had their origin from affected vines - Dr Burger explained, however, that the virus does influence the quality of the grape, and therefore wine quality.
"It has been shown that severe virus infection has detrimental effects on both sugar and acid levels of the fruit. Negative effects on plant and root growth have also been observed."
Meanwhile on a positive note, Jan Booysen, executive director of Winetech, says virus related research funding from the South African Wine Industry Trust has been increased from R6,5 million to R10 million over a ten year period (which started three years ago).
Existing research projects are also continuing, especially the focus on the following areas:
- Eradication - which includes projects to determine the current status of the re-infection problem, as well as the elimination of viral vectors
- Etiology - which includes projects to elucidate the different viral pathogens contributing to the disease complexes
- Resistance - includes different approaches to introduce virus resistance into grapevine
- Supporting technologies - encompassing several projects to develop technologies needed in many of the other areas, such as genetic transformation of grapevine, greenhouse and field trials, and the maintenance of a reliable virus reference source.
On being asked about progress being made with these projects, Dr Burger said that excellent progress in most research projects has been made over the past two years. "Especially the studies on epidemiological aspects of leafroll disease and its insect vectors."
Research results and progress are communicated during their annual Grapevine Virus Workshop when researchers report back on the previous year's progress.
"We've also had a roadshow at which a number of researchers reported back on selected topics in the programme," said Dr Burger. "This year we had two such meetings, the first was specifically aimed at nurserymen and the second at viticultural consultants. In previous years, producers from various regions were targeted."
According to Booysen, communication also takes place through the Distell and VinPro viticulturists, guidelines and protocol in WineLand, VinPro/Winetech information days, as well as the South African forum for viticulturists (SAFV).
"Although research in all the above named areas is actively being pursued, two main research thrusts have evolved," explains Dr Burger. "These are 'management practices', which include studies on the incidence and spread of the virus, all aspects of vector involvement and control, practical measures to prevent infection, and to 'manage' the disease in infected vineyards. They are short to medium term projects.
"The other thrust is the development of virus resistant grape cultivars, which we believe is the only realistic way to ultimately get rid of virus diseases. Most of these projects rely on transgene technology, which place them in a longer-term category. This is not only because of the complex nature of the work, but also because of GMO acceptance issues, especially in Europe."
And a breakthrough: "Well, maybe not a breakthrough in our industry yet, but a very interesting and exciting development is the discovery of gene silencing technology. This holds immense potential as a highly effective way to fight viruses. It has the added benefit that potentially only rootstock material needs to be genetically modified, i e the fruit (and wine) would still be GM-free. We have started a project using this technology and hope to start testing the system in transgenic tobacco later this year."
For detailed guidelines on leafroll and protocol to restrict the spread of mealybug in a vineyard block, contact Anel Andrag on (021) 807-3387 or e-mail andraga@kwv.co.za.
Research progress
- Dr Gerhard Pietersen of the ARC-PPRI recently completed his second annual survey on the incidence and spread of leafroll disease in mother blocks. This study includes spatial patterns of disease spread, the development of remote sensing as a tool for rapid data capture of disease spread, secondary spread in infected vineyards and the identification of additional viruses (i e other than grapevine leafroll virus 3) that are spreading through vineyards. A high incidence of Grapevine Virus A (GVA) infection seems to be associated with leafroll disease. Details of these research results will be published in Wynboer Tegnies shortly.
- Dr Kerstin Kruger (University of Pretoria) found in her transmission studies of leafroll virus that the highest virus concentrations were detected in first instar mealy bug nymphs (crawlers) and that these are the most likely vectors of the disease. She also reported that transmission has to occur within 8 hours, since the virus did not persist beyond this time in the insect gut.
- Other research on the mealy bug by Dr Vaughn Walton (ARC-Infruitec/Nietvoorbij) includes bio-control by mass release of natural enemies, the use of pheromones in monitoring vector numbers for designing optimal chemical control strategies, and recently, the incidence and importance of the mealy bug vector on the subterranean parts of the vine.
- Closely linked to the success of mealy bugs as virus vectors is the role of ants. Pia Addison (ARC-Infruitec/Nietvoorbij) investigates strategies of effective ant control and found that the planting of cover crops aids in controlling ant populations. She also investigates the use of toxic baits in vineyards.
- In a number of projects, Dr Dariusz Goszczynski (ARC-PPRI) is studying the causal agents of a number of grapevine diseases. The viruses causing Shiraz disease have still not conclusively been proven, but grapevine leafroll associated virus 3 (GLRaV-3) and grapevine virus A (GVA) seem to be closely associated with this emerging disease.
- Viral diagnostics is an important aspect of the research program and the development of new kits and services receives continual attention. ELISA kits for grapevine leafroll viruses 1, 2 and 3 are available, while GVA and GVA are at a late stage of evaluation. PCR-based diagnostics are available for GLRaV-3, GVA and GVB. Marika van der Merwe (ARC-PPRI) is responsible for this work.
- Virus resistance is the goal of three different projects; the first is a broad-spectrum approach in which a ribosome-inactivating protein (RIP) gene from carnations has been isolated and transferred into tobacco. Transgenic tobacco plants have since been hardened-off and will be evaluated for resistance against GLRaV-2. In a second project, a deliberately mutated form of the movement protein gene from GLRaV-3 has been transferred to tobacco. In preliminary tests, during which these plants were challenged with an unrelated virus, immunity against this virus was achieved. These plants are currently being challenged with a number of grapevine viruses to evaluate their possible resistance to these. In the final project the aim is to utilise gene silencing technology to inhibit viral replication in grapevine tissues. Preliminary silencing constructs containing the green fluorescent protein gene (from jellyfish, as an easy observable marker system) will be tested once again in a tobacco evaluation system.
International picture
Leafroll occurs worldwide in all grape-growing areas. Germany suffered an 80% leafroll infection in 1936. In Nuriootpa, Southern Australia, natural spreading of leafroll symptoms in Pinot Noir clone material was observed. In 1993, 6% of vines displayed leafroll symptoms, which escalated to 21 and 36% in 1994 and 1995 respectively. The incidence of leafroll infection over a period of five years in New Zealand increased from 11-100%. In France some vineyards are reported to be 80% infected with leafroll.
- Guidelines by Winetech